The Kansas City Royals are at a crossroads. Their 2024 campaign ended with an ALDS loss to the New York Yankees, exposing a glaring weakness: a lack of consistent offensive firepower. If the Royals want to make a deeper run in October 2025, it’s clear they need more muscle in their lineup. Fortunately, the free-agent market offers several intriguing options, and now is the time for Kansas City to make a bold move.
The Royals’ Offensive Shortfall
A Promising Core, but Not Enough
The Royals boast a solid foundation of young talent, but their lineup lacks the kind of slugger who can consistently change games. In 2024, their offense struggled to deliver in key moments, particularly against elite pitching in the postseason. Without a true power threat, Kansas City’s chances of competing with the league’s top teams remain slim.
Lessons from the ALDS Loss
The Royals’ loss to the Yankees highlighted the difference a powerful lineup can make. The Yankees’ ability to generate runs with home runs and extra-base hits underscored Kansas City’s need for a similar dynamic. To compete at the highest level, the Royals must address this deficiency.
Enter Anthony Santander: The Perfect Fit?
Santander’s 2024 Breakout Season
Anthony Santander emerged as one of the premier sluggers in baseball during the 2024 season. The switch-hitting outfielder enjoyed a career year with the Baltimore Orioles, smashing 44 home runs and driving in 102 runs. He also made his first All-Star appearance, cementing his status as a top-tier offensive player.
While his batting average was a modest .235, Santander’s power and run production more than made up for it. Over the past six seasons, he’s maintained a slugging percentage of .476, showcasing his consistency as a power hitter.
Versatility and Challenges
Santander’s primary defensive positions are the corner outfield spots, where he provides a reliable arm but below-average fielding. He’s also logged some time at first base, adding a touch of versatility. At 30 years old, Santander still has productive years ahead, making him an attractive option for teams seeking an offensive upgrade.
Could Santander Land in Kansas City?
The Cost Factor
One hurdle for the Royals in pursuing Santander is his price tag. Coming off a career year, Santander’s market value has soared. While Kansas City has historically been conservative in free agency, investing in a player of Santander’s caliber could transform their lineup and propel them into serious contention.
A Seamless Fit
Adding Santander to the Royals’ roster would address their most pressing need. His switch-hitting power bat would provide balance to the lineup, while his ability to drive in runs would take pressure off younger players. Santander’s presence could also elevate the team’s offensive production in high-leverage situations.
The Royals’ Path Forward
Why the Royals Should Take the Leap
Kansas City’s window for contention is opening, but their young core needs support to maximize its potential. Signing a player like Santander would signal the Royals’ commitment to winning and energize the fanbase. While the financial investment is significant, the potential payoff—a deeper postseason run and sustained success—justifies the cost.
Other Options to Consider
If Santander proves too expensive, the Royals could explore alternative options in the free-agent market. Players with similar power profiles but lower price tags could still provide a boost to the lineup. Additionally, Kansas City could look to make a trade, leveraging their farm system to acquire a slugger.
Predictions for the 2025 Season
With Santander
Should the Royals land Santander, their lineup would gain a legitimate middle-of-the-order threat. His presence would likely lead to an increase in home runs, RBIs, and overall offensive efficiency. Kansas City could emerge as a dark horse contender in the American League, capable of challenging powerhouses like the Yankees and Astros.
Without Santander
If the Royals opt against making a splashy signing, their path to success becomes more challenging. While their young talent offers promise, the lack of a proven slugger could limit their postseason aspirations. Kansas City would need several players to exceed expectations to remain competitive.
Recommendations for the Royals
- Make a Bold Move: The Royals should prioritize adding a power hitter, even if it means stretching their budget. Santander represents a unique opportunity to transform their lineup.
- Explore All Options: If Santander is unattainable, the Royals must identify other impactful players who fit their needs.
- Develop Internal Talent: Alongside external additions, Kansas City should continue to nurture their young players, ensuring long-term success.
- Invest in Pitching Depth: While addressing the offense is critical, bolstering the pitching staff will also be essential to building a well-rounded contender.
Conclusion: A Crucial Offseason for Kansas City
The Kansas City Royals face a pivotal offseason as they aim to build a team capable of competing deep into October. Adding a slugger like Anthony Santander could be the game-changing move they need. Whether they open their wallet or explore creative alternatives, the Royals must address their offensive shortcomings to maximize their potential in 2025. With the right moves, Kansas City could reestablish themselves as a force in the American League.